Mining Incidents
Fatality · MSHA Record #220230940002

Bulldozer Operator

February 26, 2023 at 3:50 PM
GRAPEVINE SOUTH SURFACE MINE · Surface · Coal
Contractor on site: A7147
Mingo County, WV
Classification MACHINERY
Type Struck against a moving object
Investigator narrative
Employee was mobilizing dozer to work site for following day via haul road. Cause of accident unknown. Employee went over embankment and was found approx. halfway down mountain. Details unknown at this time. Employee found deceased. No eye witnesses.
Final MSHA investigation
On February 26, 2023, at 1:08 p.m., Billy Mapes, a 73 year-old contract bulldozer operator with approximately 53 years of mining experience, died when he was ejected from the operator’s cab of the bulldozer he was operating. The bulldozer traveled over the edge of Haul Road 3 and rolled 375 feet down an embankment before coming to rest. The accident occurred because: 1) the mine operator did not conduct an examination of the working area, and 2) the contractor did not ensure that the bulldozer operator wore a seat belt while operating the bulldozer.
Root causes
  1. The mine operator did not conduct an adequate examination of the working area.

    Corrective action: The mine operator developed and implemented a new written procedure that requires all examiners, including contract examiners, to communicate the findings of all examinations of work areas to mine management on the day the examinations are completed prior to conducting work. The records of the examinations will be maintained in the mine office. The mine operator trained all miners and contractors on the new procedure.

  2. The contractor did not ensure that the bulldozer operator wore a seat belt while operating the bulldozer.

    Corrective action: The contractor developed and implemented a new written procedure that includes increased emphasis on compliance with the regulation requiring seat belts. This new procedure includes increased frequency of safety meetings to ensure compliance.

Read the full report (PDF)

Findings from MSHA's final investigation report, which supersedes the preliminary narrative above.

Record details
Activity at time of incident
Bulldozer
Subunit / location
STRIP, QUARY, OPEN PIT
Accident type
Struck against a moving object
Source of injury
SURFACE MINING MACHINES
Nature of injury
UNCLASSIFIED,NOT DETERMED
Body part affected
MULTIPLE PARTS (MORE THAN ONE MAJOR)
Total mining experience
53 years
Experience in this job
53 years
Degree of injury
FATALITY
Verify on MSHA

Every record on this page mirrors what MSHA publishes under its Open Government Data program, refreshed weekly. MSHA does not publish per-accident URLs (the Accidents data is distributed as a single bulk file), so this is how to retrieve the source for the specific record below:

Source: US Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) · Document 220230940002 · Mine ID 4608930 Trainer view →