Mining Incidents
Fatality · MSHA Record #220210270015

Shuttle Car Operator

January 22, 2021 at 7:45 AM
Davy Branch Mine · Underground · Coal
Logan County, WV
Classification POWERED HAULAGE
Type Struck by powered moving object
Investigator narrative
#2 shuttle car was traveling back toward #5 entry to turn down towards feeder, and the #3 shuttle car was already traveling this entry when the #2 car came thru the fly pad they contacted the operators compartment of the #3 car injuring the operator. The EE died on 2/21/21, autopsy results state EE died as the result of a thromboembolism.
Final MSHA investigation
On January 22, 2021, at 7:44 a.m., Justin L. Lafferty, a 38-year-old shuttle car operator with approximately 11 years of mining experience, was injured when another shuttle car struck the operator’s compartment of the shuttle car he was operating. On February 21, 2021, Lafferty died as a result of the injuries sustained during the accident. The accident occurred because the mine operator did not have policies or procedures in place to assure safe underground haulage when: 1) mobile equipment traveled through a transparent ventilation curtain (flypad), and 2) shuttle cars from different mechanized mining units (MMU) shared a common intersection where flypads are used.
Root causes
  1. The mine operator did not have policies or procedures in place to assure safe underground haulage when: 1) mobile equipment traveled through flypads; and 2) shuttle cars from different MMUs share a common intersection where flypads are used.

    Corrective action: The mine operator revised their approved ventilation plan addressing haulage equipment traveling through flypads. The revision includes discontinuing the practice of shuttle cars from different MMUs sharing a common intersection where flypads are used. Mine management trained all miners on the revised policies and procedures which were incorporated in the Approved Ventilation Plan. Miners also received training on Safeguard No. 9291763 issued as a result of the investigation (see Enforcement Actions item 2).

Read the full report (PDF)

Findings from MSHA's final investigation report, which supersedes the preliminary narrative above.

Record details
Activity at time of incident
Shuttle Car, Ram Car, Buggy
Subunit / location
UNDERGROUND
Underground location
INTERSECTION
Mining method
Continuous Mining
Accident type
Struck by powered moving object
Source of injury
MINE JEEP,KERSEY,JITNEY
Nature of injury
OTHER INJURY,(Not Elsewhere Classified)
Body part affected
MULTIPLE PARTS (MORE THAN ONE MAJOR)
Total mining experience
11 years
Experience at this mine
0 years
Experience in this job
7 years
Degree of injury
FATALITY
Verify on MSHA

Every record on this page mirrors what MSHA publishes under its Open Government Data program, refreshed weekly. MSHA does not publish per-accident URLs (the Accidents data is distributed as a single bulk file), so this is how to retrieve the source for the specific record below:

Source: US Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) · Document 220210270015 · Mine ID 4609574 Trainer view →