Mining Incidents
Fatality · MSHA Record #220200020010

Beltman

December 23, 2019 at 4:30 PM
MARSHALL COUNTY MINE · Underground · Coal
Marshall County, WV
Classification MACHINERY
Type Caught in, under or between a moving and a stationary object
Investigator narrative
A fully trained miner was fatally injured while attempting to remove a splice pin from a 72" mechanical belt splice. The splice was positioned near the outby side of the tail frame. The victim was positioned between the bottom conveyor belt and the top conveyor belt. Investigation is on-going by company, state and federal officials.
Final MSHA investigation
On December 23, 2019, at approximately 4:15 p.m., Raymond "Ray" Starkey Jr. (Starkey), a 21-year old general inside laborer, was fatally injured when he was caught between the 72-inch wide belt and the steel frame of the belt tailpiece. The accident occurred because the assembly holding the Cameron Corridor belt in place was not strong enough to withstand tension created during the belt move. The mine operator used belt grippers, lever hoist chains, and lever hoists that were not designed to withstand the forces generated during the move.
Root causes
  1. The Cameron Corridor belt was not adequately blocked against motion during the belt move.

    Corrective action: The mine operator revised and expanded their belt move procedure. The revised procedure requires the belt splice to be positioned at least 100 feet outby the tailpiece. It also requires all belt tension to be removed, which eliminates the need to clamp the belt near the tailpiece. Miners were trained in the revised procedure.

  2. Adequate supervision was not provided while the victim was being task trained.

    Corrective action: The mine operator trained miners who perform the supervised portion of task training to ensure trainees are safe while they are being trained.

Findings from MSHA's final investigation report, which supersedes the preliminary narrative above.

Record details
Activity at time of incident
Machine Maintenance
Subunit / location
UNDERGROUND
Underground location
LAST OPEN CROSSCUT
Mining method
Other
Accident type
Caught in, under or between a moving and a stationary object
Source of injury
BELT CONVEYORS
Nature of injury
FRACTURE,CHIP
Body part affected
SKULL
Total mining experience
2 years
Experience at this mine
0 years
Experience in this job
0 years
Degree of injury
FATALITY
Verify on MSHA

Every record on this page mirrors what MSHA publishes under its Open Government Data program, refreshed weekly. MSHA does not publish per-accident URLs (the Accidents data is distributed as a single bulk file), so this is how to retrieve the source for the specific record below:

Source: US Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) · Document 220200020010 · Mine ID 4601437 Trainer view →